Hello Dr. Steve and thank you for your time and expertise. I am writing because I would love some advice on dog food. We have a 2-year-old Australian Labradoodle who has been really healthy. She is medium, 35 pounds and has been this weight for about a year now. I am finding the pet food industry very overwhelming and confusing, everywhere I turn, I get a piece of different advice. She has been eating about 50% kibble and 50% raw (NW Naturals frozen nuggets) for over a year. She does not enjoy the kibble and if fed without the raw, she will walk away from it. Our vet says that her diet is not balanced. Our vet also recommends feeding a grain-inclusive diet (due to risk of DCM). Do you have a recommendation on what would be a good food to feed our put for optimal health if we were to buy already prepared balanced food (fresh/frozen, etc)? What is your opinion on food such as Ollie, NW Naturals (grain free), etc? Thank you!
Dr. Steve's Advice - congratulations on taking a look at changing up the diet. I know it sounds bewildering, but it really doesn't have to be. AAFCO sets a very low but adequate bar for nutritional completeness that most raw and even home cooked diets could readily leap. If you're contemplating a particular raw or cooked fresh food diet, ask the company (or the store where you're buying it) regarding which of their foods meet AAFCO standards.
Alternatively, you can cook your own. It is as effortless to create a balanced diet for your dog as for yourself. Gold Standard Herbs and Aleksandra Topic provide recipes for making your own food in the Featured posts above. I know from personal experience that the Gold Standard diet will produce a food that meets AAFCO standards and is essentially an embellishment of a home made diet created by a board certified veterinary nutritionist.
The two diets you mention are air dried diets. Studies show they still contain significant levels of AGEs, pro-inflammatory compounds formed during the heating and drying of foods, so I don't see them as a great alternative to kibble, personally. Freeze dried would be much better if you must feed your dog out of a bag.
I don't personally recommend what you're doing now, which is feeding half kibble and half real. I know many people advocate that as much better than all kibble, with studies that back up their stance. Personally, though, I notice that dogs on half kibble and half real food have the same medical problems as dogs on all kibble diets. From my perspective as a clinician, the half measures just don't really cut it.
Hopefully this helps you out!
Click here to read the whole thread.